It was somewhat disappointing. Its texture is patchy and it doesn't write boldly. Long stay ok. But it is like a transparent black

I have been buying it for years. It is convenient for quick application. It has a vivid color and a matte finish. It does not dry quickly!

It arrived in my hands unsealed and completely dry. However, there may be an issue with some batch of Maybelline for this specific product because even after I bought it from a well-known cosmetics store, I had the same problem again, completely dry.

The worst eye liner I have ever bought, it doesn't even write. I thought it might be a fluke so I bought a second one and it still didn't write like the first. Don't even make the mistake of getting it because it has a good price. 0/10

Useless product. It doesn't write from the first moment, you press it and it doesn't leave color, it makes a gray line as if it has run out and has no color inside. I had bought another Maybelline eyeliner and that one didn't write either, I contacted the company and they sent me this, even worse. Very simply, I will never buy eyeliner from this company again

Useless product, you open it and it's dry like it's finished, it writes with difficulty and only vertically.. do you make a line vertically??? I threw it away on the spot. Don't buy it.

Although the brush has a fine tip, the color does not come down well resulting in the tip not writing. Very thin-flowing color on the first application. Bad product unfortunately :/

To run the liquid inside and make a line, you have to hold it vertically, which means it is incredibly difficult to create an eyeliner line. At first, I thought it was defective. Unfortunately, it is a disappointing product that I would not buy again. The only positive thing is the tip that makes application easy, but it does not release enough quantity to do the job

I bought it and it was like it was finished. It didn't produce any color, only a gray shade. Disappointing..

I expected more from this specific eye liner, which I bought in large quantities due to work. Unfortunately, it does not write at all, as if the color has run out. This results in a lack of uniformity in the line and it almost doesn't write at all! Disappointed!

I have been using this eyeliner for years without any problems, but this is my first time purchasing it from this specific store. This one seems like it doesn't have any ink and it doesn't have a good result at all. Normally, I should have returned it as defective.

Do you want to learn how to apply eyeliner with the pen tilted? If yes, this is the perfect eyeliner!
Within a week, the tip bends and breaks, resulting in the color not reaching the edge. For those who say it dried... no, it didn't dry! It has a very intense black color. You just have to learn to use it like a shovel (!!) and preferably, cursing! Money wasted.

The product, although it was in black color, "watered" quite a bit, for example, if you had dipped it in water... when you use it in the first application, it's fine, but as soon as you want to go over it again, it's like erasing the line underneath and creates this "watering"

Very good .. easy application .. material on the brush just enough, so as not to smudge during application .. I have been buying it for the last 8 years because I am very satisfied.

It dried up after 10 uses and the tip didn't release ink, so I had to cut it and now it dried up again. Terrible, I won't buy it again for anything

Unfortunately, it does not have very good results. I bought it for a more intense, everyday use at the office instead of my talika one that I have been using for years. It disappointed me. I will go back to talika. The only positive thing is its brush. Very good

I was looking for a waterproof eyeliner because I often tear up and smudge my makeup! This eyeliner literally saved me! It is very easy to use, it has a thin tip like a pen so it is indeed very precise, and even if you tear up, it doesn't come off while it is easily removed with eye makeup remover. Finally, it is also very affordable, so 5 stars from me!

I am very satisfied with the product! Just got it, thin brush draws fine lines, perfect for me. You rub it and it hardly comes off, which shows that it is waterproof! I highly recommend it!

Very good choice with long-lasting results. Its brush provides precision and even on hot days, the result is very stable, it does not run. Clearly value for money.

I have been using it for years, and compared to many eyeliners at the same price, it is the best! Very easy application, intense black color, and long-lasting even in the summer with warm and oily eyelids. With daily use, it definitely lasts for 4-5 months. The brush takes a long time to dry

All the youtubers were raving about how it's the best eyeliner and very long-lasting and intense and, and, and... It's incredibly unstable. Within 10 minutes, it smudges on the upper eyelid. Especially if you have a slight drooping eyelid like me, forget it... Also, if you have it open for a while trying to create the perfect line (which, okay, takes some effort, you can't do it in 3 seconds), it dries quickly and the color doesn't come out intense... Overall, a disappointment considering how much they praised it.

Intense color, easy to remove. You can easily make a mistake though, maybe I would prefer a thicker brush

I was incredibly disappointed. For some reason, the tip of the eyeliner dried out (even though I always made sure to close it tightly) and it wasn't black, it was dark gray.

I don't know if the product I bought was defective, but the lid didn't close, resulting in it constantly opening when I carried it in my bag and drying out. The tip was very flexible, which also made it difficult for me. Of course, if it didn't dry out, there might not have been any problem.

Excellent color, accuracy, and long-lasting on the eye even on oily eyelids. The downside, however, is that it dried out on my third use, and both times I purchased it, it was not just a defective product.

You did one eye and it went well, but when you tried to do the other, the color didn't come out easily, but it has good lasting power. Average pen.

I first use an eyeliner pencil and then apply this because I can't draw easily. Intense color, long-lasting, doesn't smudge. It is easily removed. I believe it is worth its money.

When the circulation of the eyeliner I had been using for years stopped within a 6-month period, I had purchased around 10 pen-style eyeliners and finally ended up with this one.... It is perfect because its color is intense, it doesn't leave gaps, it doesn't ruin the brush except when it runs out, it doesn't break, and yet it easily comes off when I remove my makeup...!

I give it four stars because the five stars are taken by the Maybelline eyeliner pen.
Honestly, this product in pen style is very easy to use, especially for beginners, it is just what you need.
Intense color, the only downside with pen style is that if you have it for a long time and apply it over pigment or glitter, the pen loses its performance, gets dirty, dries out, and the tip can bend and not give precision to the look. This product has a good tip that doesn't bend easily. However, it is a pretty good product.

A very good product. Its performance is very good and its durability is long. Also, its tip is quite thin, but it dried out in about a month.