On my swatches, the very top one is the discontinued Nyx gypsy blue, a teal color slightly metallic, in a retractable packaging. After moving to Greece after 18+ yrs in the US I was looking for a good substitute since the nyx one has been discontinued. Peacock 424 is a great dupe but with visible gold and silver shimmer and slightly less blue than Gypsy Blue. (Another even more accurate dupe is the Kiko intense colour liner in 11). They're all creamy but Peacock and Plum apply more effortlessly than Jam. Next to Peacock on my hand are Plum (a medium purple) and Jam on the right (a burgundy). On my foto I'm wearing Peacock on my waterline and it's after 6 hrs of applying it and having been in the heat and active so it holds up pretty well. It does need reapplication after 7hrs. The plum one lasts longer in my waterline. I've ordered Raisin and Lagoon and I'll get more colors for sure.

Very nice shades! I got the electric blue and the petrol for brown or hazel eyes, they are perfect. The only disadvantage is that it runs out very quickly, you have to sharpen it regularly, but I guess that's because it's soft, which means you apply it once and that's it. I wouldn't change it, I threw away all the other eye pencils with which after an hour I looked like Bozo! This one lasts even though it's soft, it's worth it

Stable over time, silky as it says, rich color that doesn't leave gaps, its disadvantages are 1. It burns the eyes (at least the sensitive ones) if applied to the upper or lower waterline and 2. It runs out quickly, needs sharpening after each use.

While I used to consider it a top product, I have now started to have reservations. I don't know what has changed in its composition or technology, but half the pencil gets eaten up by the Erre Due sharpener. Very fast wear, every single time it needs sharpening, resulting in it being used up extremely quickly and becoming impractical. Really, Erre Due, you need to bring back the previous technology, in which the pencil was durable, otherwise we will turn to other brands.

It melts and smudges very easily. Every time I have worn it, after a while my eyes look like a little bear. I do not recommend it

Amazing pencil, very soft, the best I have tried so far. You need to be careful not to press it too hard because it colors very easily. With other pencils, I would go over and over the eye. Amazing!

Very good, doesn't smudge, stays put for hours, but unfortunately the tip keeps breaking and a quarter goes to waste

The best. I have been using it for years.. I have bought more expensive brands but nothing.. in a few hours they become rugs.. I have tried many others but in the end, nothing compares to this!!!

I have all the shades, it is stable without staining, it has intense color that lasts and with the appropriate eye makeup remover it comes off easily. The disadvantage is that it is very soft, I use an eyeliner sharpener from Erre Due and with one turn it is fine

Color Maple 404. If I could give it 10 stars, I would. The color is a lovely sweet metallic brown. It doesn't overpower the look at all. While it is soft, buttery, and you're afraid it will melt in the next half hour, it stays put forever, until you decide to remove it!
As for how easily it applies, what can I say? Even a beginner can easily draw a line on the upper eyelid, even on the thin one. It outperforms pencils that cost multiple times more. Of course, I will buy the same one again and I will also try other colors.

It doesn't come off at all! It still "comes off" even after 3 days, even though I have removed it again and again and again.
At least for me, who has dry skin, it is a hassle.

It really lasts all day!!! While it is soft, it does not smudge. I have bought almost all shades

The pencil tip breaks very easily while sharpening. Otherwise, it has long-lasting durability and stability throughout the day

The best thing I have ever used! I use it for bridal makeup but also for myself! It doesn't smudge, it can be worked before it dries and then it becomes waterproof!

Very poor durability. Whether I apply it internally or on the eyelid, it smudges after a while. The gel eye pencil from essence is better, more affordable, and stays on the waterline.

Indeed the most durable eyeliner pencil I have ever bought. It doesn't smudge and doesn't smear. For the first time, the color doesn't come off on my eyelids as soon as I open my eyes and it lasts until the evening! The only drawback is that it is very soft and finishes quickly with daily use.

I have been using the silky eye pencil for maybe 13 years. There is no better pencil that I have personally used. I have quite sensitive eyes and they tear easily with eye products. I didn't have a problem with this pencil and it has a steady application, I don't end up looking like a panda.

Yes, yes, and again YES! I have combination oily skin, I have tried many eyeliners, some of them were good and some were so-so, but they always smudged on my eyelid. No matter how much powder I applied or how much I set it!
I applied this at 12 noon and intentionally did not remove it at night and slept with the pencil. The next morning it was still in place on my eyelid and under my eyes, but I was completely clean! Unbelievable pencil, I will definitely buy it again!
P.S. It requires a gentle application because it is very soft, and it would be good to have a very thin flat brush to draw the line if you want, depending on the time, like an eyeliner!

I have oily eyelids and pencils are generally forbidden for me. This one is the only one that stayed in place without even applying primer. I highly recommend it.

By far the best pencils I have tried, they spread easily and with stability. I call them tattoos!