I have started to appreciate this eyeliner a lot for the fact that you can achieve a cat eye in two moves! If it lasted and didn't come off so easily, I would give it 5 stars.

I have been using this specific eyeliner for a month now, among others. I can confidently say that it is not as intense as I am used to. It is more of a soft black rather than the "black" it appears in the packaging. It reminds me of some Korean eyeliners. It's not bad, I can say that the result on my skin is simply more subtle and natural than usual. It doesn't last for many hours, which means that it will require some touch-ups to have a satisfactory result. A positive aspect is that it doesn't cause irritations and it easily comes off without leaving any residue.

The worst eyeliner there is. It barely gives any color, I tried applying it a second time and it just smudged. It only gives color when you press the thick part of the brush, which makes no sense. It's not worth wasting money on.