9 out of 10 Only because the painting could be painted with a little more detail (I judge strictly this is supposedly what I didn't like) Now that I've answered the second part of the question, let's move on to the good... It has a surprise, too (I won't say why because I'll spoil it) if I say it It's a perfect investment and quality with a hard cover #AND.... Here is the good... It's a real story if you want to make your child a detective without them knowing I recommend it for everyone who has hope for the future.