I've had it for 5 years. Up to 140 km/h, which is as fast as I've gone, there's neither noise nor any other disturbance. I put it on the car for the 10-15 days of vacation and then store it away, and nothing has happened to it.

I have exactly the same one for almost 15 years (I bought it for 99€ at Carrefour!). In terms of space, we're talking about a second trunk! In terms of quality, it's mediocre at best, considering that I only used it for two weeks a year on vacation and then stored it, yet the top part got corroded by the sun and turned from black to gray! I recently restored it with a polish, but I don't know how long it will last. For that price, it was great, but considering the price I see now, if they haven't improved the quality, I don't think it's worth it. Also, the attachment system is secure but outdated, resulting in struggling to fit the hooks onto the bars, especially if they're not in a standard position. That's all, I hope I helped.

Yesterday on the mountain, the bases of the Suzuki Jimny's rails broke, causing the roof rack to detach from a height of about 2 meters and land upside down on rocks, etc. It had some lightweight items inside, of course (a camping chair, a tent, and a bag). It didn't suffer anything except for a couple of scratches.

It's great for the money it costs. Minimal noise up to 120-130 km. No stability issues due to wind and very small increase in fuel consumption.

The truth is that I have no image of other roof boxes, but personally, I don't know what more you could want that this one doesn't have. It has a large space, easy installation with the special fasteners, nice closure, and minimal noise on the road. If you're not into design and brand, this roof box covers 100% of the needs and does the job it is intended for at a low cost.

I bought it for 150 euros 3 years ago, and for that money, it was perfect. However, it's not worth it at 190 euros, especially now that for an extra 20-30 euros, you can get a much better one